Business Structure Comparison Australia: A Practical Guide for SMEs
- 3 days ago
- 8 min read
Choosing the right business structure in Australia is a foundational decision that significantly impacts your tax obligations, personal liability, and administrative workload. The core choice is whether to operate as an individual (sole trader), with partners, or through a separate legal entity like a company or trust. Each path offers a different balance of protection, complexity, and cost, making a careful business structure comparison essential for any Australian enterprise. This article is based on the 2025–26 Australian Financial Year.
Based on our experience at Baron Tax & Accounting, many new Brisbane entrepreneurs initially choose the sole trader structure for its simplicity. However, they often overlook the unlimited personal liability that comes with it. We've seen growing trades businesses, for instance, needing to quickly transition to a company structure to protect the family home from mounting business debts and supplier risks.
A quick snapshot of the four main structures includes:
Sole Trader: You and the business are legally the same. It's simple and cheap to start, but your personal assets are fully exposed to business risks.
Partnership: Two or more people run a business together. It allows for pooled resources, but partners are generally jointly liable for all business debts.
Company: A separate legal entity offering limited liability, which protects personal assets. It is more complex and costly to set up and maintain.
Trust: A structure where a trustee holds assets for beneficiaries. It provides strong asset protection and tax flexibility but is the most complex to manage.
The Four Core Business Structures Explained
Laying the right foundation starts with choosing the correct business structure. Each of the four main options in Australia comes with its own unique blend of simplicity, liability, cost, and compliance obligations. Getting this choice right from day one can save you from significant administrative and financial challenges later.
Sole Trader
The sole trader structure is the simplest and most common entry point for individuals starting a business. Legally, you and your business are a single entity. This provides you with complete control, and setting up is fast and inexpensive—often only requiring an Australian Business Number (ABN).
The primary drawback is unlimited personal liability. If your business incurs debt or faces legal action, your personal assets, such as your home and car, are at risk. All business income is taxed at your individual marginal tax rate. For a deeper analysis, you can compare the sole trader vs company structure in our detailed article.
Partnership
A partnership is formed when two or more people or entities run a business together. It's an effective way to pool capital and skills and is relatively simple to establish. It is highly advisable to have a formal partnership agreement to define responsibilities, profit distribution, and exit strategies.
The most significant risk is joint and several liability. This means each partner is responsible not only for their share of business debts but for the entire amount. If one partner defaults, creditors can pursue the other partners for the full debt.
Company
A company is a separate legal entity from its owners (shareholders). Its main advantage is limited liability, which generally protects the personal assets of directors and shareholders from business debts and legal claims. This makes it the preferred structure for businesses planning to grow, seek investment, or manage significant risk.
This protection comes with higher setup costs and a greater administrative burden. Companies are regulated by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and have more complex tax and reporting obligations. For the 2025–26 Financial Year, company profits are taxed at a flat corporate rate of 25% for businesses with an aggregated turnover of less than $50 million.
Trust
A trust is an arrangement where a person or company (the trustee) holds and manages assets for the benefit of others (the beneficiaries), governed by a legal document called a trust deed.
The primary benefits of a trust are asset protection and tax flexibility. Income can be distributed among beneficiaries to take advantage of their individual marginal tax rates, potentially minimising the overall tax paid. However, trusts are complex and expensive to establish and maintain, requiring expert legal and accounting advice. They are commonly used for family businesses and investment purposes. You can explore a detailed comparison in our article on family trust vs company structure.
Business Structure Comparison Table
To understand the practical differences, it helps to compare these structures side-by-side across the factors that matter most: liability, tax, cost, and compliance.
Feature | Sole Trader | Partnership | Company (Pty Ltd) | Trust (Discretionary) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Asset Protection | None. Personal assets are at risk. | None. Personal assets of all partners are at risk. | High. A separate legal entity protects personal assets. | High. Assets are held by the trustee, offering protection. |
Tax Rate (2025–26) | Individual marginal tax rates. | Partners taxed at individual marginal rates. | 25% (for base rate entities) or 30%. | Beneficiaries taxed at individual marginal rates. |
Setup Cost | Very low. | Low. | High. | Very high. |
Ongoing Compliance | Low (Individual tax return). | Medium (Partnership tax return). | High (ASIC reviews, company tax return). | High (Trust tax return, trustee resolutions). |
Liability | Unlimited. | Unlimited (joint and several). | Limited to company assets. | Generally limited to trust assets. |
Best For | Freelancers, contractors, new low-risk ventures. | Professional services with multiple active owners. | Growth-focused businesses, those with employees or significant risk. | Family businesses, asset protection, and investment holding. |
The trade-off is clear: simpler structures offer ease and low cost but expose you to personal risk. More complex structures provide robust protection and tax flexibility but demand a higher level of administrative effort and ongoing costs. Understanding your obligations for ABN and tax return compliance is crucial from the start.
Real-World Scenarios: Which Structure Should You Use?
The best structure depends entirely on your industry, goals, and personal situation. A structure that’s perfect for a freelance designer would be unsuitable for a fast-growing tech startup. Let's examine some practical examples.
Sole Trader: For Freelancers and Side Hustles
The sole trader structure is ideal for individuals selling personal skills with low overheads and minimal risk.
Example: A freelance copywriter in Sunnybank can obtain an ABN online for free and start operating immediately. Their business income is treated as personal income, simplifying tax returns. The main consideration is that they are personally liable for any business debts.
This structure is perfect for:
Testing a business idea with minimal financial commitment.
Side hustles or small-scale ventures.
Low-risk, service-based professions.
Partnership: For Professional Collaborations
A partnership works well when two or more professionals with complementary skills team up, such as in accounting firms, law practices, or medical clinics.
Example: Two architects in Brisbane form a partnership to combine their expertise and capital, allowing them to bid on larger projects than they could individually. A comprehensive partnership agreement is essential to manage the risk of joint and several liability.
Company: For Growth and Liability Protection
The company structure is the standard choice for any business with growth ambitions, employees, or significant operational risks. It creates a separate legal entity, shielding the owner's personal assets.
Example: A Brisbane-based construction business operates as a company. This ensures that if the business faces a lawsuit or financial difficulty, the director's personal assets, like their family home, are protected. This structure is also necessary for startups seeking to raise capital from investors.
Trust: For Asset Protection and Family Businesses
A trust is a powerful structure for protecting assets and managing wealth, particularly for family-run businesses and holding high-value assets.
Example: A family-owned manufacturing business is held within a discretionary trust. The trustee (often a company for added liability protection) manages the business, and profits can be distributed tax-effectively to family members (beneficiaries) each year, minimising the family's overall tax burden.
When and How to Change Your Business Structure
The sole trader setup that was perfect for your startup can become a liability as your revenue, assets, and team grow. Knowing when to transition to a more robust structure is a critical strategic decision.
Key Triggers for a Structural Change
Growing Personal Risk: Your personal assets (e.g., family home) are exposed to business debts.
Tax Inefficiency: Your profits push you into higher personal income tax brackets, making the 25% corporate tax rate more attractive.
Bringing on Partners or Investors: You need a formal structure to issue shares and raise capital.
Hiring Staff: A company provides a clearer framework for employer obligations like superannuation.
Credibility: Larger clients or government contracts may require you to operate as a registered company.
The Transition Process
Changing your business structure is more than an administrative update. If moving from a sole trader to a company, you are creating a new legal entity.
Steps:
Register New Entity: Register a company with ASIC or have a trust deed drafted.
Obtain New ABN/TFN: The new entity requires its own ABN, TFN, and other tax registrations (GST, PAYG).
Manage Asset Transfers: Moving business assets (vehicles, equipment) to the new entity can trigger Capital Gains Tax (CGT). Small business CGT concessions may apply but require careful planning.
Update Agreements: All contracts, leases, and insurance policies must be updated to the new company's name.
A common oversight is underestimating the administrative follow-through. Forgetting to update a major client contract or bank accounts can create significant legal and operational issues.
Checklist for Choosing Your Structure
This checklist helps focus on the practical factors that should guide your decision.
Personal Liability
Are you willing to risk your personal assets for the business? If not, a company or trust is necessary.
Is your business in a high-risk industry (e.g., construction)? If yes, liability protection is essential.
Growth Ambitions
Do you plan to hire employees? A company structure simplifies payroll and superannuation obligations.
Will you need to raise capital from investors? A company is the only viable structure for issuing shares.
Compliance and Costs
How much time and budget can you dedicate to administration? Sole trader is simplest; companies and trusts require more resources.
Have you factored in ongoing professional fees for accounting and legal advice?
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can I run multiple businesses under one ABN? Yes, a sole trader can operate multiple business lines under one ABN. However, all income is consolidated for tax purposes, and there is no liability separation between them. For any venture with significant risk, a separate company is advisable.
2. How do I pay myself from my business?
Sole Trader/Partnership: You take "drawings" by transferring money to your personal account. You are taxed on the total business profit.
Company: You are paid a salary as a director/employee, which is a tax-deductible expense for the company.
Trust: You receive a "distribution" of profits as a beneficiary and pay tax on it at your marginal rate.
3. Is a separate business bank account necessary? For sole traders, it's not legally required but highly recommended by all accountants to avoid administrative chaos. For companies and trusts, it is a legal requirement as they are separate legal entities.
4. Which structure is best for property investment? A trust, often with a corporate trustee, is generally preferred for property investment. It offers excellent asset protection and tax flexibility by allowing income and capital gains to be distributed strategically among beneficiaries.
5. What is the difference between a director and a shareholder? A director is responsible for managing the company's day-to-day operations and ensuring it meets its legal obligations. A shareholder owns the company by holding shares but is not typically involved in daily management unless they are also a director.
Summary
Sole Trader: Simple and low-cost, but offers no personal asset protection. Best for low-risk individual ventures.
Partnership: Good for collaboration, but all partners face unlimited joint liability.
Company: Provides strong liability protection and a scalable structure but has higher setup and compliance costs. The standard for growth-oriented businesses in Brisbane.
Trust: Offers superior asset protection and tax flexibility, ideal for family businesses and investments, but is the most complex.
Key Consideration: The right structure depends on your personal risk tolerance, growth plans, and tax situation. Re-evaluating your structure as your business evolves is critical.
Need clarity on your situation?
This article provides general information for educational purposes. Choosing the right business structure has significant and lasting legal and financial consequences that depend entirely on your individual circumstances. The information here does not constitute financial or legal advice.
For guidance tailored to your specific business goals and financial situation, consulting with a qualified accountant or lawyer is essential. Professional advice ensures you select a structure that provides the right balance of protection, flexibility, and compliance for your needs.
Official ATO Reference
For further details from the Australian Taxation Office on business structures and their tax implications, please refer to the following official resource:
Baron Tax & Accounting
Website: https://www.baronaccounting.com Email: info@baronaccounting.com Phone: +61 1300 087 213 Whatsapp: 0450 468 318
Comments